General Satisfaction score :
Treato analyzes billions of patient discussions to understand what patients are saying about their experience with regard to their treatments, diseases and side effects. Treato algorithmically identifies patients' positive experiences about medications within their Web posts, for example acne that cleared up, high blood pressure that was reduced, a certain drug that "worked", and so forth. Treato aggregates all of these discussions to calculate how many positive patient posts each medication received, relative to other drugs. Note that positive patient posts about medications are always aggregated in relation to a specific condition, since the same medication may be used for more than one condition.
See what millions of patients are saying
Can we help?
Join now!

Arthritis

Ask a question
510,752
Discussions
Ask a question
Arthritis is a form of arthropathy that involves inflammation of one or more joints.There are over 100 different forms of arthritis. ...
Read on Wikipedia
Common Arthritis treatments discussed around the web
Methotrexate 11,397 Prednisone 8,270 Glucosamine 6,524
510,752 conversations around the web about Arthritis to help you make a decision
510,752 conversations around the web about Arthritis to help you make a decision
Ask a question

Compare medications for Arthritis

Ben Gay
VS.
Ibuprofen
Other name: Icy Hot (Icy Hot)
Other name: Advil (Advil)
5 / 10
Satisfaction
Not enough data
Satisfaction
16,270
Discussions around the web
Discussions
403,142
Discussions around the web
Discussions
Taken for:
by discussions around the web
Pain
Muscle Pain*
Arthritis
Inflammation
* Off label
Taken for:
by discussions around the web
Pain
Headaches
Swelling
Inflammation
Cramping
Fever
Pain Relief
Migraines
Back Pain
Arthritis
Teething
Flu
Show more
Method of use:
Gel, Ointment
Method of use:
Gel, Ointment
Prescribing mode:
OTC
Prescribing mode:
OTC
Bengay, spelled Ben-Gay prior to 1995, is an analgesic heat rub used to relieve muscle and joint pain. It was developed in France by Dr. Jules Bengu , and brought to America in 1898. The name Bengu was anglicized to Bengay. It was originally produ...
Read on Wikipedia
Ibuprofen (International Nonproprietary Name) ( or from the nomenclature iso-butyl-propanoic-phenolic acid) is a nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID) used for relief of symptoms of arthritis, fever, as an analgesic (pain...
Read on Wikipedia
Top Concerns
Ben
Nausea
2
Withdrawal
2
Addiction
2
Diabetes
2
Heart Attack
1
Not Sleeping
1
Lack Of Sleep
1
Sneezing
1
High Blood Pressure
1
Stomach Problems
1
Top Concerns
Ibu
Numbness
7
Depression
5
Addiction
5
Withdrawal
4
Stomach Problems
3
Rash
3
Blood Clots
3
Dehydrated
3
Sleepy
2
Drowsy
2
Compare concerns
By:
Ben Gay
Ben
Ibuprofen
Ibu
Nausea
Ben
Ibu
2
0
Withdrawal
Ben
Ibu
2
4
Addiction
Ben
Ibu
2
5
Diabetes
Ben
Ibu
2
0
Heart Attack
Ben
Ibu
1
0
Not Sleeping
Ben
Ibu
1
0
Lack Of Sleep
Ben
Ibu
1
0
Sneezing
Ben
Ibu
1
0
High Blood Pressure
Ben
Ibu
1
0
Stomach Problems
Ben
Ibu
1
3
Numbness
Ibu
Ben
7
0
Depression
Ibu
Ben
5
0
Addiction
Ibu
Ben
5
2
Withdrawal
Ibu
Ben
4
2
Stomach Problems
Ibu
Ben
3
1
Rash
Ibu
Ben
3
0
Blood Clots
Ibu
Ben
3
0
Dehydrated
Ibu
Ben
3
0
Sleepy
Ibu
Ben
2
0
Drowsy
Ibu
Ben
2
0
Back
About Ben Gay
Bengay, spelled Ben-Gay prior to 1995, is an analgesic heat rub used to relieve muscle and joint pain. It was developed in France by Dr. Jules Bengu , and brought to America in 1898. The name Bengu was anglicized to Bengay. It was originally produ...
Read on Wikipedia
Read more about:
Ben Gay
About Ibuprofen
Ibuprofen (International Nonproprietary Name) ( or from the nomenclature iso-butyl-propanoic-phenolic acid) is a nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID) used for relief of symptoms of arthritis, fever, as an analgesic (pain...
Read on Wikipedia
Read more about:
Ibuprofen

Your Saved Posts ()

We found 377 discussions
that Ibuprofen does nothing for me. The only thing that...
" ...I find that Ibuprofen does nothing for me. The only thing ...that ultimate strength Bengay is really nice. My neck and shoulders are always bothering me - and that... "

I am living on ibuprofen and it's not helping all that much....
" ...it to radiate. I had physical therapy and it got better but it never went away. I think I need to go back to the doctor. I put bengay on my lower back every night and that helps but I... "

taking ibuprofen every 3 hours..it's helped somewhat but...
" ...it along with taking ibuprofen every 3 hours..it's helped somewhat but my wrist still feels stiff..i have a little ...anything with it..i put some bengay on it and it feels alot better..we'll ha... "

doesn't work I use Transvasin. And Ibuprofen or Tylenol...
" ...an increase in pain and rustiness of the joints and also an elevated body temperature. Hot baths, massages with BenGay or when this doesn't work I use Transvasin. And Ibuprofe... "

precautionary thing. I feel great today after the ibprofen...
" ...a little inflammation? Still gonna put some bengay on it tonight ...What are those? I'mma use bengay tonight on my back. Final precautionary thing. I feel great today after the ibprofen "

Post from
www.wemove.org
Have you tried prescription Ibuprofen at night? 600...
" ...Have you tried prescription Ibuprofen at night? 600 ...Also, what about Klonopin? It is a muscle relaxer. I find that it works well, and it ...menthol cream (like Ben Gay) which makes my s... "

Ibuprophen 800 mgs .. doesn't work. BenGay ... doesn't...
" ...trying to figure out how to manage and I don't want to use. Ibuprophen 800 mgs .. doesn't work. BenGay ... doesn't work. Ice packs don't work. Cold packs don't work. I'm in so much... "

Dr told me to take 1,200 mg ibuprofen daily (rip my stomach...
" Hey Guys. I have severe carpal tunnel in both left and right side. My Dr told me to take 1,200 mg ibuprofen daily (rip my stomach out ...Smells FAR better than bengay and works awesome. I am a... "

Post from
www.prevention.com
even have to take ibuprofen; the BenGay isn't doing much....
" ...a journey--now it's in the middle of my lower back and sometimes it stabs me so I feel like I'm getting tasered. I had planned to do some yoga, but I think a rest day is in order instead. Might ... "

out, what I did was use ibuprofen then some pain killers if...
" ...use ibuprofen ...as bengay but stronger. Then everyday after workouts go through a routine of restrengthing the rotator cuffs with dumbbells and cables. This seem to be the only thing that help ... "

Back to Signup